John Carter was desperate to find his missing fiancée, Katelyn Markham, who disappeared in August 2011. He reported her missing the next day and spent years pleading for her return. However, more than a decade later, he was indicted for her murder. Just before the trial, prosecutors agreed to drop the murder charge if Carter pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter, to which he agreed. He was sentenced to three years in prison.
Butler County Prosecuting Attorney Michael Gmoser explained that he pursued the case for justice for Markham, even if Carter’s sentence seemed light. Carter’s defense team and family refused to comment, but Carter’s lawyer stated that he had taken accountability for Markham’s death.
Before her disappearance, Markham had been dating Carter for five years and was planning to move to Colorado with him. Carter’s alibi of watching shows on his computer the night Markham vanished was brought into question, and witness accounts of seeing his car at odd hours added to the suspicion.
Investigators found poems in Carter’s journal that hinted at a dark motive for Markham’s death. Despite a lack of direct evidence linking Carter to the murder and uncertainty about the cause of death, prosecutors believed there was enough circumstantial evidence to proceed with the case.
Gmoser decided to accept a guilty plea for involuntary manslaughter to ensure accountability from Carter, even though other potential charges were time-barred. The plea agreement provided closure for Markham’s family, even though the exact circumstances of her death remain unclear.
Photo credit
www.nbcnews.com
